All the gear, no idea

The new Thorne’s catalogue came out a few days ago. I picked up a copy during a visit to the Newburgh store when I bought frames for the upcoming season and some more queen excluders.

Required reading

Required reading

I’ve always enjoyed reading the Thorne’s catalogue. Browsing the 2018 copy brought back memories of my introduction to it a decade or so ago. That was after my very first “Beekeeping for Beginners” evening class with the Warwick and Leamington beekeepers. Everyone left the class clutching a catalogue and an order form for a discounted BBwear suit. 

It was clearly effective and well-targeted marketing. I still spend more than I should (though less than I could, thanks to my catastrophic DIY skills) with Thorne’s and I still use BBwear suits.

Pick a size, any size

Dadant? Smith? Aargh!

Dadant? Smith? Aargh!

The abiding memories of my first experience of the catalogue were the myriad choices … of hives, frames, foundation, tools and – perhaps more than anything else – labels and moulds.

Remember, this was before even the basics of the hive had been introduced in the beginners course. That first evening was probably spent on the distinction between queens, workers and drones, or perhaps ‘the beekeeping year’.

Back to the catalogue … surely there wasn’t the need for all those different frame sizes and styles? DN1, DN2, DN4, DN5, 14″ x 12″ and BS Manley.

Hang on! What happened to DN3’s? 1

And then the hives … National, Commercial, Dadant, Smith, Langstroth … Aargh!

Very confusing. And that’s before some of the hives that didn’t even really look like beehives were considered … Top bar, Dartington, Warré 2 etc.

Of course now, a decade or so later, I know the answer. There’s no logical need for anything other than medium Langstroth boxes and one type of frame 😉

But I and most other beekeepers also know that logic is something in short supply in most beekeeping.

Indeed, logic is almost as rare as adhering to standards.

Which is why I use BS ‘British Standard’ National hives 😉

The essentials and nothing else …

The Thorne’s catalogue3 lists everything an amateur ‘hobbyist’ beekeeper could possibly need and almost everything he or she could possibly want. It also lists several thousand things that are either duplicates of other stuff or, plain and simple, are probably unnecessary.

Eight different types of smoker. Eleven different types of uncapping knives, forks or rollers. Eighteen different types of hive tools. Eighteen! And I daren’t even look at the labels or moulds.

This isn’t a criticism. Choice is great … but is can be really confusing. Particularly when you don’t know the difference between your Bailey, Horsley, Snelgrove, Cloake or Snuggle boards.

Have some sympathy for the hundreds of tyro beekeepers attending winter training courses all over the UK at the moment. In between those two hour lectures in the drafty church hall 4 they’re feasting on the Thorne’s catalogue every evening to provide their necessary daily ‘fix’ of beekeeping enlightenment.

For many, this catalogue is an integral part of their beekeeping education.

Beetradex and the Spring Convention

And then, schooled in basics from their winter training courses and simultaneously confused and enticed by their nightly perusal of the ‘essentials’ in the Thorne’s catalogue, come the two biggies.

Beetradex and the BBKA Spring Convention.

Like lions waiting to ambush an unsuspecting baby wildebeest, the two biggest trade events in the beekeeping year allow all those essential items in the catalogue to be seen, inspected, caressed, agonised over and – finally – bought.

Beetradex ...

Beetradex …

Not necessarily in that order.

In my case sometimes bought, caressed, inspected and then agonised over 🙁

What on earth possessed me to get a Combi-Brush?

All the gear, no idea

Those early beekeeping days were characterised by limitless enthusiasm – in part fueled by the annual Thorne’s catalogue – and precious little practical experience.

"Essentials" ...

“Essentials” …

I’ve still got stuff I bought in those early days. There’s all sorts of bits and bobs stored away which ‘might come in’.

It hasn’t and probably won’t 🙁

One of the characteristics of my beekeeping (and I suspect of many others) is that it has become much simpler and more straightforward as I’ve gained experience 5. The enthusiasm is still there, it’s just tempered with pragmatism and an appreciation that there’s only so much I can fit into the garage.

Enlightened apiculture

I now carry less to the apiary than I did five years ago. The bee bag is slimmed down and much more manageable. My record keeping is more organised – or at least less shambolic. I’ve given away the frame rests, mouseguard magnet … and the Combi-brush.

But, most significantly, I’ve pretty-much standardised on the equipment I use. I buy the boxes ensuring that they’re all compatible with each other. I buy the replacement frames and I buy less and less foundation.

And most of the rest I usually do without or build myself. The latter includes almost all of the ‘horizontal’ components of the hive – the floor, boards, roof, ekes etc.6

And I reckon my beekeeping is better for it. My bank balance certainly is 🙂

What’s new?

Nevertheless, I’ve still enjoyed a quiet hour or two (as the Beast from the East roars outside) with a cup of tea and the 2018 Thorne’s catalogue.

I’ve marvelled at the Adapta hive stand and floor which, by my estimates, would cost an eye-watering £422.92 if you were to buy it with all the accessories.  Actually, I’ve mainly marvelled at their ingenuity in designing all those accessories. This floor has been out a year or two now, but new for 2018 is the Adapta eke.

Or perhaps that should be Eek!

Undoubtedly well made, indubitably multi-functional, but costing £107.50 with all the add-ons.

Eek!

My first hive was a secondhand Thorne’s Bees on a Budget National bought from an association member who had had to give up beekeeping due to allergies. The boxes are still in regular use. It’s still listed in the catalogue and thousands have probably started their beekeeping with one of these hives.

While the basic hive hasn’t changed there are lots of new choices of floor, half-size supers and insulation, polish containers, queen introduction cages and – inevitably – candle moulds.

So … was I tempted by anything?

Of course 😉

Horsley board

Horsley board

A year or two ago Thorne’s started selling Horsley boards (PDF) – an interesting method of swarm control consisting of a split board with an upper entrance, removable slide and queen excluder panel. I built my own a few years ago and have used it successfully. Mine is bodged together from bits of scrap wood and a butchered tin baking tray.

It’s a monstrosity.

They had one in the Newburgh store and it was beautifully made.

I was very tempted.

But I managed to resist … though I’ve looked at it several times in the new catalogue 😉


Colophon

In the interest of literary accuracy I should add that the bit about the Combi-Brush is not entirely true. I’ve never bought one. It was chosen as the most ridiculous piece of beekeeping equipment I could find in the catalogue that readers might appreciate.

However, there are a few things I have bought that, years, months, weeks or just days later, I’ve wondered … “Why?”

What they are will remain a closely guarded secret 😉

Footnotes

  1. DN3 frames have a thin (9mm) narrow (22mm) top bar and, like DN1’s and 2’s, need spacers. I’ve never seen them available commercially and Dave Cushman comments that it “suffers badly from wax moth attack”. There’s also a DN6 frame – just to confuse you further. This was a self-spacing (Hoffman-type) variant of the DN3 frame.
  2. Actually, I’m pretty certain that Warré hives weren’t even in the Thorne’s catalogue a decade ago. However, there were other odd-looking hives in their place. Of course, if I’d been a 19th Century French beekeeper or a Kenyan beekeeper from Laikipia County I’d have wondered how a WBC worked … I still do.
  3. For US readers the Mann Lake catalog (see what I did there?) is probably most similar of those I’ve seen.
  4. Other drafty venues with poor lighting, uncomfortable chairs and a noisy urn are available.
  5. Excluded from this comment is any attempt to fully copy Snelgrove’s instructions for his eponymous board.
  6. But not queen excluders … though some people make their own.

8 thoughts on “All the gear, no idea

  1. Janet Wilson

    I too enjoy trialling new equipment! It is part of the fun of the hobby, but it does get expensive. Over the years my “go-to” beekeeping kit has slimmed down as well. I have my faves, and my own way of doing things and everyone has to figure that out for themselves. My local bee supplier stocked a new model of hive tool last year and it is the best I have ever used. The hook end actually works well for levering up frames, unlike all my other hive tools, and I retooled my entire apiary (I keep a hive tool on every crown board/inner cover as a disease control measure). But her biggest customer came in and complained about them! And…lots of folk are going all medium boxes these days, but I find all deeps works best for me. Ditto 8 frame boxes…tried them and did not like that approach so I am back to all 10 frame, which I find more efficient.

    Reply
    1. David Post author

      Hi Janet
      I know some people who solely use deeps … they’re really heavy when full. Your 8 vs. 10 frame boxes are a more logical way to increase/decrease volume than our standard broods or 14 x 12’s (or, horrors, brood and a half), all of which involve different frame sizes.
      Apiary hygiene is important, but I draw the line at a separate hive tool per hive. I assume that all the bees within the same apiary are essentially ‘the same’. There’s so much drifting between colonies that they probably share any and all diseases they may have, whether you use a different hive tool or not. I just have a bucket of soda in each apiary which I keep hive tools in and avoid using the same hive tool in different apiaries.
      And, you’re absolutely right, everyone has to work out what’s best for their own particular style of beekeeping.
      David

      Reply
  2. Emily

    “Perhaps that should be eek” – this made me chortle inside.

    …Is it wrong that I now want a combi-brush? Is this actually a combi-brush marketing piece?

    Reply
    1. David Post author

      I think there’s going to be a huge resurgence in demand for Combi-Brushes … I’ve warned Brian at the Newburgh branch of Thorne’s that he’ll need to stock up to avoid having to turn away disgruntled customers 😉

      I think the increased demand for this type of multi-tool will inevitably lead to the development of an Adapta combi-brush for 2019, with a range of expensive replacement ‘ends’ … magnifying glass and LED lights, lighter for the smoker, queen catching cage, backscratcher etc.

      You heard it here first 😉
      David

      Reply
      1. Emily

        Now you’re talking. The goal should be to fit every piece of beekeeping equipment you could ever need into this one tool. The most elusive task for me remains the ability to drink a cup of tea through a veil – if anyone could invent such a device, and combine it with a brush – perfection!

        Reply
        1. David Post author

          We’re making progress though we have yet to solve the ‘cup of tea’ problem. We’ve also run into a few technical issues with the ’20-frame radial extractor’, but perhaps we’re simply being too ambitious.

          More seriously … you can drink directly through the veil of your bee suit. I do on a hot day, though not tea just bottled water. It feels a bit odd at first, but you soon get used to it … just make sure there are no bees in the way.
          David

          Reply
  3. Richard

    Have you seen this? I posted a few months ago about the kewl floors and the possibility of stopping Asian Hornets. I saw this online and wondered what your thoughts were. Could it be incorporated into a kewl floor? Seems, in essence, to be a kewl floor anyway.

    Best wishes, Richard.

    Reply
    1. David Post author

      Hi Richard
      I had a look at Vita’s Apishield hornet trap a few months ago at one of the conventions. It’s essentially an open mesh floor with a removable ‘box’ into which hornets can enter, but cannot leave. The bees orientate to the standard hive entrance and then the openings to the ‘box’ are, er, opened so that the scent of the colony attracts hornets. It’s not inexpensive (but is cheaper than the Adapta floor 😉 … there’s a thought, perhaps a new board for the latter can be created?) and I’ve not heard from anyone in France using it. The floor was very well made if I remember rightly (it was 18+ months ago now) so should be a good investment if it works well.

      My concern is that the AH’s I’ve seen in videos seem to be attracted to the hive entrance, presumably because that’s where all the bee activity is. Perhaps they first explore every other opportunity to access the colony. I’d want to see good evidence it worked well before investing – either the time to make my own (in which case there’s no reason a kewl floor design couldn’t be created) or money to buy it outright – but certainly don’t see any reason it wouldn’t be beneficial.

      David

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *