Finding the queen

One of characteristics that distinguishes inexperienced and experienced beekeepers is the time taken finding the queen. Generally an experienced beekeeper will be much, much faster. Not every time – anyone can have a good day or a bad day – but on average.

A local queen

A local queen

An inexperienced beekeeper will carefully scrutinise every frame, turning it end over end with the half-way rotation they were taught during the midwinter beekeeping beginners course they attended. They’ll examine the end bars and the bottom bar. They’ll look again at either side of the frame and will then slowly return it to the box.

The experienced beekeeper will gently open the hive and lift out the dummy board and the adjacent frame. They’ll look across the remaining seams of bees before splitting them somewhere in the middle. They’ll lift out the frame on the nearside of the split and expect to find the queen on it or on the frame on the far side of the split.

And they usually do.

Magic?

No, experience. And not necessarily in actually spotting the queen. Mostly this experience is in better handling of the colony in a way that maximises the chances of seeing the queen.

In the couple of paragraphs above I hinted at these differences. The beginner goes through the entire brood box thoroughly. The experienced beekeeper ‘cuts to the chase’ and splits the box at or near the middle of the brood nest.

The beginner takes time over the scrutiny of every frame. The time taken by the beginner – probably coupled with additional smoking of the hive – disturbs the colony. Disturbance results in the bees becoming agitated, which causes the beginner to give them a couple more puffs of smoke … all of which unsettles the colony (and the queen) further. Ad infinitum.

In contrast, the experienced beekeeper only bothers with the frames on which the queen is most likely to be present. The experienced beekeepers is quick, as gentle as possible and causes as little disturbance as possible … and probably uses only a small amount of smoke.

Focus where needed, skip the rest

Locally bred queen ...

Locally bred queen …

With minimal disturbance the queen will be in or around the brood nest. She’ll almost certainly be on a frame with eggs, young larvae and ‘polished’ cells. Polished cells are those that have been prepared by the workers ready for the queen to lay in. They usually have a distinctive shiny appearance to the inner walls; this is particularly easy to see if the comb is old and dark.

There’s little chance the (undisturbed) queen will be on sealed brood and even less chance she’ll be wandering around on frames of stores. All that time taken by the beginner examining a frame of sealed stores contributes to the disturbance of the colony and reduces the likelihood of the queen being where she should be.

The experienced beekeeper splits the box at or near where s/he expects to find eggs and very young brood. There’s probably only a couple of frames in the box that are at the right stage and it’s experience – of the concentration of bees in the seams and the behaviour of those bees – that allows most of the other frames to be safely ignored.

Reassuring but unnecessary

The reality is that, during routine inspections, finding the queen is not necessary. The only times you have to find her is when you’re going to manipulate the hive or colony in a way that necessitates knowing where the queen is e.g. an artificial swarm or vertical split.

The rest of the time it’s sufficient to just look for the evidence that the queen is present. The first of these is the general temperament of the colony. Queenless colonies are usually less well tempered. However, this isn’t alone a dependable sign as lots of other things can change the temper of the colony for the worse e.g. the weather or a strong nectar flow stopping.

The key thing to look for is the presence of eggs in the colony. If they are seen the queen must have been present within the last 3 days. In addition, the orientation of the eggs – standing near vertically or lying more horizontally – can provide more accurate timing. Eggs start vertical and end horizontal over the three days before they hatch. This is usually sufficient evidence that the queen is present.

Of course, just finding eggs isn’t sufficient evidence that the colony isn’t thinking of swarming. To determine that there are other things to check for e.g. the rate at which eggs are being laid and the presence or absence of queen cells, but I’ll deal with these in more detail some other time.

Stop looking

If you still feel the need to see the queen on every inspection my advice is to stop looking for her … at least consciously. Instead, concentrate on what really matters. Look for the evidence that the colony is queenright, by comparison with your notes work out whether the queen is laying more or less than at the last inspection, observe the laying pattern and look for signs of brood diseases.

By doing this you’ll predominantly be concentrating on the frames the queen is most likely to be on anyway. By doing this with minimal disruption to the colony the queen should remain undisturbed. Instead of running around frantically she’ll be calmly seeking out polished cells to lay eggs in. Therefore your chances of finding the queen are increased.

Observe the behaviour of bees to other bees on the frame – not by staring at every bee, but by quickly scanning for normal and unusual behaviour. Get used to the rate they walk about on the frames, their pattern of movement and how closely they approach each other.

When undisturbed, the queen is the one that looks out of place. She’s bigger of course, she walks about with more purpose and often more slowly than other bees. The workers make way for her, often parting as she approaches and closing up again as she passes. She may stop regularly to inspect cells or to lay eggs. Bees may be more attentive to her than to other bees. She’s the odd one out.

If you’re intent on finding the queen, stop searching and start seeing.

May the force be with you.

Mid-season memories

Mid-season memories …

14 thoughts on “Finding the queen

  1. Calum

    Excellent piece. & don’t forget to check the frame with queen cups you purposely left centrally in the hive for larvae..

    Reply
    1. David Post author

      Ah ha! Don’t give away all the secrets Calum! I’m pretty certain they never use many of the ‘play cups’ that are prepared. I’ve always meant to make some notes on the top bar and check them more frequently, but often find they’ve quickly knocked up a couple of new ones which are now charged. I usually tear off the obviously old – or at least ageing – cups during inspections so I can judge their enthusiasm for swarming when I next inspect.
      Cheers
      David

      Reply
      1. Calum

        I always leave the Queen cups on now, if you always remove them the bees get creative at hiding them.
        So then I can check for swarming by just tipping up the top brood box and checking cups. Then pull out the drone frame (it is frame 7 I start by removing frame 8) check that and frame 6 for young larvae/ queen cells and I am done… I can get through 20 hives in an hour and a half if the wife is waiting behind the door for me….

        Reply
      1. Edward

        If you only knew, everything.. Think Ill read these posts to the bees tell them what they are supposed to be doing, you mentioned the frame with drones above is this a super frame or special frame with cells for drone only. thanks.

        Reply
        1. David Post author

          Calum can reply … remember that I suspect his hive is not a National, so the frame positions might not be the same. In my hives with foundationless frames I get quite a bit of drone brood, often towards the outside of the brood nest. The bees put it where it suits them …
          Now wait for Calum to contradict everything I’ve just said … 😉
          David

          Reply
          1. Calum

            Hi
            My frames are about langstroth size. I usually have 2 broodboxes and a super. The lower brood box is just brood frames, in the top brood box frame 3 or frame 7 or both will be drone frames (foundation free frames). As the majority of queen cups are on the lower surface of the upper brood box, I can top it up to check them after removing the super..

  2. Edward

    Thanks I just had a Eureka moment there reading this again, I suspected it was a super frame with drone cells drawn on the bottom. But why shouldn’t it be a standard national frame (as I use national hives) with it filled with 1/3 comb as a starter and they will draw drone brood on the rest, I am getting the hang of this or at least having my own ideas at last. (:)) Tell me I am on the right track.

    Reply
    1. David Post author

      The bees will tell you soon enough 😉
      First cutting of the graph around my apiary today … that suggests that things will be starting in the next fortnight or so if the weather holds. The Ribes has been flowering in sheltered parts for at least three weeks, but it’s been far too cold for inspections.
      I hope your season is a good one.
      David

      Reply
    2. Mike

      For drone culling – so you can slice the drone comb off with one deft move of the hive tool.
      Though in practice it can be quite tough, requires 3 hands, and you typically end up knocking over the bucket you were hoping it would drop into.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *