Robbery

Robber

Robber

Another apiculture-flavoured tale of daylight robbery, literally, to follow the post on hive and bee thefts last week.

However, this time it’s not dodgy bee-suited perps with badly inked prison tats offering cheap nucs down the Dog and Duck.

Like other offenders, the robbers this week wear striped apparel, but this time it’s dark brown and tan, or brown and yellow or black and yellow.

I am of course referring to honey bees and wasps (Vespa vulgaris and V. germanica), both of which can cause major problems at this time of year by robbing weak colonies.

Carb loading

The season here – other than for those who have taken colonies to the heather – is drawing to a close. The main nectar sources have more or less dried up in the last fortnight. There’s a bit of rosebay willow herb and bramble in the hedgerows and some himalayan balsam in the river valleys, but that’s about it.

Colonies are strong, or should be. With the dearth of nectar in the fields, the foragers turn their attention to other colonies as a potential source of carbohydrates. Colonies need large amounts of stores to get through the winter and evolution has selected a behavioural strategy – robbing of weaker colonies – to get as much carbohydrate from the easiest possible sources.

Like the nucs you carefully prepared for overwintering 🙁

At the same time, wasps are also wanting to pile in the carbs before winter 1. In the last fortnight the wasp numbers in my apiaries and equipment stores have increased significantly.

Jekyll and Hyde

Within a few days in late summer/early autumn the mood and attitude of colonies in the apiary changes completely.

During a strong nectar flow the bees single-mindedly pile in the stores. They alight, tail-heavy, on the landing board, enter the hive, unload and set out again. There’s a glut and they ignore almost anything other than bingeing on it. Inspections are easy. Most bees are out foraging and they are – or should be – well-tempered and forgiving. 

Laden foragers returning ...

Laden foragers returning …

But then the nectar flow, almost overnight, stops.

Colonies become markedly more defensive. They are packed with bees and they’re tetchy. There’s nothing to distract them, they resent the intrusion and they want to protect their hard-won stores 2.

At the same time, they quickly become more inquisitive, investigating any potential new source of sugar. If you shake the bees off a frame and leave it standing against the leg of the hive stand there will be dozens of foragers – many from nearby colonies – gorging themselves on the nectar.

If you spill unripened nectar from a frame they’re all over it, quickly forming a frenzied mass – probably from several different hives – scrabbling to ‘fill their boots’.

They also closely investigate anything that smells of nectar or honey. Stacks of equipment, empty supers, hive tools, the smoker bellows … anything.

Robbing

And it’s this behaviour that can quickly turn into robbing.

The foragers investigate a small, dark entrance that smells of honey … like a nuc in the corner of the apiary. They enter unchallenged or after a little argy-bargy 3, find the stores, stuff themselves, go back to their colony and then return mob-handed.

Before long, the nuc entrance had a writhing mass of bees trying to get in, any guards present are soon overwhelmed and, in just a few hours, it’s robbed out and probably doomed.

This is the most obvious – and rather distressing – form of robbing. Wasps can do almost exactly the same thing, with similarly devastating consequences.

Prevention is better than cure

Once started (and obvious), robbing is difficult to stop. About the only option is to seal the target hive and remove it to another apiary a good distance away.

Far better to prevent it happening in the first place.

The best way of preventing robbing is to maintain large, strong and healthy colonies. With ample bees there are ample guards and the colony will be able to defend itself from both bees and wasps. Strong colonies are much more likely to be the robbers than the robbed.

For smaller colonies in a full-sized hive, or nucleus colonies or – and these are the most difficult of all to defend – mini-nucs used for queen mating, it’s imperative to make the hive easy to defend and minimise attracting robbers to the apiary in the first place.

The underfloor entrances on kewl floors are much easier to defend than a standard entrance and small entrances are easier to defend than large ones. ‘Small’ might mean as little as one bee-width … i.e. only traversable by a single bee at a time.

Smaller is better ...

Smaller is better …

You can even combine the two; insert a 9mm thick piece of stripwood into the Kewl floor entrance to reduce the space to be defended to a centimetre or two. If – as happened tonight when returning wet supers to the hives – I don’t have a suitable piece of stripwood in the apiary I use a strip of gaffer tape to reduce the entrance 4.

Gaffer tape is also essential to maintain the integrity of the hive if some of the supers are a bit warped. Wasps can squeeze through smaller holes than bees and the quick application of a half metre along the junction between boxes can save the day 5.

The poly nucs I favour have a ridiculously large entrance which I reduce by 90% using foam blocks, dried grass, gaffer tape, wire mesh or Correx.

Correx, the beekeepers friend ...

Correx, the beekeepers friend …

Don’t tempt them

Finally, reduce the inducement robbers – whether bees or wasps – have to investigate everything in the apiary by not leaving open sources of nectar, not spilling honey or syrup, clearing up brace comb and ensuring any stored equipment is ‘bee proof’.

You don’t need to inspect as frequently at this time of the season. The queen will have reduced her laying rate and colonies are no longer expanding. With no nectar coming in they should have sufficient space in the brood nest. There’s little chance they will swarm.

If you don’t need to inspect, then don’t. The ability to judge this comes with experience.

If you do have to inspect (to find, mark and clip a late-season mated queen for example 6 do not leave the colony open for longer than necessary. Any supers that are temporarily removed should be secured so bees and wasps cannot access them.

Wet supers

If you’re returning wet supers after extraction, do it with the minimum disruption late in the evening. These supers absolutely reek of honey and attract robbers from far and wide. Keep the supers covered – top and bottom – gently lift the crownboard, give them a tiny puff of smoke, place the supers on top, replace the roof and leave them be.

Returning wet supers

Returning wet supers …

In my experience wet supers are the most likely thing to trigger a robbing frenzy. I usually reduce the entrance at the same time I put the wet supers back and try to add wet supers to all the colonies in the apiary on the same evening 7.

I generally don’t inspect colonies until the supers are cleaned out and ready for storage.


 

Footnotes

  1. I’m not entirely sure I understand why though … they’ve been rearing young all season on a protein-rich diet of insects but switch to carbs in the early autumn. Most of the wasps involved in robbing will die off during the first frosts of winter.
  2. Lots of anthropomorphisation going on here … all these are simply behavioural traits driven by evolution.
  3. Nucs often have poorly balanced bee populations, with lots of young bees and few guards, for example.
  4. Don’t just slap a strip of tape across the entrance as you’ll find there are a line of dead bee stuck to it when you remove it. Instead, fold a strip lengthways and stick it to itself. Stick this narrow, now non-adhesive strip, lengthways along the middle of a second strip. Then seal the entrance. It’e easier to do than write! Use waterproof gaffer tape.
  5. Wasps and bees can chew through this sort of tape; it’s useful for temporary ‘fixes’ and to prevent access in the first place.
  6. Really? If there are eggs present and pollen going in she’s probably OK. She’ll be easier to find in the Spring as there will be far fewer bees in the box.
  7. Theoretically so no one colony is induced to rob others as they’re all too busy with the bounty that’s just been dumped on top of their own home. In reality, I don’t know whether this really makes a difference.

6 thoughts on “Robbery

  1. Ray

    We’ve got a terrible problem with wasps this year in Lincolnshire. More wasps than I can remember for many a year. I’m adding robbing screens for wasps rather than bees this year!

    Reply
    1. David Post author

      Hi Ray
      Wasps seem ‘smarter’ than bees in finding their way in … this year they’ve leant to negotiate the overlapping window panes in our bee shed and are being a real nuisance. I’ll be interested to hear whether they learn to circumvent your robbing screens. I’ve not discussed these as I’ve never really used them.
      Cheers
      David

      Reply
  2. Emily

    I thought the reason wasps start to crave sweetness in late summer/autumn was that previously their larvae excreted sugar. With the queen no longer laying worker larvae, they no longer have this sugar source so turn to rotten apples, honey and ice cream.

    I made the mistake of eating a ‘hedgehog’ on the beach this week – vanilla ice cream rolled in clotted cream and honey covered hazelnuts. You can imagine the result. Poor Tommy had them crawling on his face trying to get his ice cream dribbles.

    Reply
    1. David Post author

      Hi Emily
      You might well be right, but I’m not sure I see why … those getting the ‘fix’ are all doomed and most won’t breed. There must be some sort of explanation in terms of evolution (I’m a biologist – it’s what explains almost everything where money isn’t involved, in which case it’s economics). Something to look into during the long winter ahead.
      The ‘hedgehog’ sounds absolutely disgusting, let alone what happened to Tommy. Just because those four ingredients are delicious doesn’t necessarily make the combination appealing!
      David

      Reply
      1. Emily

        Maybe a basic survival instinct to keep going as long as possible? Or because they still have a few queens and males to bring up in the autumn?

        You’re wrong about the hedgehog – it was fabulous, even with several wasps trying to steal it!

        Reply
        1. David Post author

          Possibly … seems a selfish act without reproductive benefit if there aren’t queens being produced.
          I’m still unconvinced about the ‘hedgehog’ 😉
          Regards
          David

          Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *