Pagdens’ artificial swarm

Every beekeeping association that runs a winter course for beginners will teach swarm control. In almost every case they use the artificial swarm method that evolved from that promoted by James Pagden (1814-1878). So universal is this teaching that the terms ‘Pagden’ and ‘artificial swarm’ are used almost interchangeably.

Swarm control – defined below – is an important skill in beekeeping. It saves your bees from bothering the neighbours and by not losing swarms you increase your honey crop. Furthermore, understanding the principles may help apply some related queen rearing techniques.

I’m planning a few posts on swarm control this season and realised I’d never described the ‘classic’ artificial swarm – possibly because I don’t often use it. To avoid referencing other sites with more or less comprehensive (or correct) descriptions I’ve catalogued the ‘bare bones’ of the process here.

Swarm control

A small swarm

A small swarm …

Swarm control and prevention are two different things. The latter are the steps taken to stop a colony from ‘thinking’ about swarming, e.g. young queens and ample space. In contrast, swarm control are what is needed once there are signs that swarming by the colony is imminent. The most common sign is the discovery of unsealed, charged (i.e. occupied) queen cells during an inspection. You practise swarm prevention to prevent, or at least delay, the need for swarm control. Once swarm control is needed many beekeepers use Pagdens’ artificial swarm.

If you discover sealed queen cells during an inspection there’s a good chance your swarm prevention didn’t work and that it’s too late for swarm control. Colonies with unclipped queens usually swarm when the developing queen cells are capped. If there are sealed queen cells and no sign of the queen or eggs then they’re probably hanging in a tree or occupying a bait hive by now.

The artificial swarm

Pagdens' artificial swarm ...

Pagdens’ artificial swarm …

The principle of the artificial swarm is to separate the queen and flying bees from the brood and nurse bees. This is achieved by a couple of simple colony manipulations. These exploit the tendency of flying bees to return to the location of the hive they were reared in, or more accurately, the location of the hive from which they took their orientation flights. If you remember this it all makes sense.

The diagram is colour coded. The original hive location is the centreline of the image. The old hive is mid-grey, the new hive is light-grey. Brood-containing frames are red, foundation or drawn comb is black. The queen is indicated Q (black if mated, white if a virgin or recently mated). The timings of the manipulations are indicated.

Day 0 and Day 1

Don't panic

Don’t panic …

During a routine inspection of a strong colony anytime from mid-April to late June (depending upon the season) you discover unsealed, charged queen cells. Don’t panic. Collect the necessary equipment for an artificial swarm – a complete new hive consisting of a floor, brood box and full complement of frames (preferably some or all are drawn comb, the rest can be just foundation – or foundationless frames), a crownboard and a roof. An additional hive stand is also useful, though not essential.

In the diagram I’ve assumed that it takes a day to collect this lot and get back to the apiary … whatever, once you’re ready, proceed as follows.

  1. Move the old hive a couple of metres away from the original location. If there are supers present remove these and the queen excluder first, putting them aside.
  2. Place the new floor and filled brood box on the original site, with the entrance facing the same way as before.
  3. Remove two frames from the centre of the new brood box.
  4. Gently go through the old hive. Find a frame of open brood. Shake the frame gently to dislodge the flying bees, inspect it carefully, place the queen onto the frame and put it into the centre of the new brood box. There must be no queen cells on this frame.  Push together the adjacent frames and add a spare frame so the hive is full.
  5. If there were supers present at the start place them on the new hive above the queen excluder. If there were no supers you might need to feed this colony some thin syrup to encourage them to draw new comb.
  6. Add the crownboard and roof to the new hive.
  7. Push together the frames in the old hive, add one more frame, put the crownboard and roof back and leave them to get on with things.

What does this first manipulation achieve?

At the end of this first manipulation you’ve manually separated the queen from almost all the brood and nurse bees. The queen is in the original location in the new hive. All the flying bees will return to the original location – because that’s where they first orientated to – over the next day or so. This new hive is viable as it contains a mated queen, bees to support her and lots of empty space for her to lay in.

The old hive is also viable, but only of they first rear a new queen. Since there are open queen cells present these must be sealed to allow pupation and metamorphosis which takes 7 days.

Day 7

Move the old hive to the opposite side of the new hive. A couple of metres away is fine. Flying bees that have matured in the old hive during the preceding week will find the hive missing when they return from foraging. They’ll most likely enter the hive closest to the hive they flew from, which is the one with the queen in it i.e. the new hive on the original hive stand. This boosts the strength of the queenright colony. More importantly, it depletes the old hive of bees, making it less likely that they’ll throw off a cast if more than one virgin emerges§.

It’s important that the old hive is not interfered with after the first 7 days. There will be a new virgin queen present who will be going out on mating flights a few days after emergence. Leave this hive untouched for at least another fortnight. In the diagram above the black frame in the old hive indicates that the oldest brood is emerging, leaving plenty of young bees to tend to the newly mated queen and ample space for her to lay in due course.

Day 21+

The old hive should now contain a newly mated and laying queen. Inspections of this colony can start again. The new colony – on the original site – should be building up well.

If you want to increase your colony numbers (make increase), you’ve done so. If you don’t want to make increase then the two colonies can be united over newspaper. Remove the old queen first, either terminally (!) or by giving her to another beekeeper.

I tend to prefer a vertical split for two reasons – it uses less equipment and it takes up less space. However, the underlying principles of the two processes are very similar as will be discussed in a future post.

 Day 0 and Day 1 can be done on the same day. I’ve separated them on the assumption that you’re as badly prepared as I am and don’t have piles of spare equipment waiting to be used in the apiary. The only thing to be sure of is not to let the queen cells be capped. If necessary knock back all the visible queen cells … once they’ve decided to swarm they will start more.

 I can never write those words without hearing them uttered in the voice of Lance Corporal Jones from the sitcom Dad’s Army. Since this was broadcast between 1968 and 1977 writing that last sentence makes me feel rather old.

§ I’m trying to steer well clear of the thorny problem of how many queen cells to leave in the old hive. That’s a separate topic in its own right. Some suggest letting the bees decide (i.e. do nothing), others leave one or two.

15 thoughts on “Pagdens’ artificial swarm

  1. Al

    This is great thanks. A straightforward, go to guide/reminder with exactly the right level of detail I’m looking for.


    1. David Post author

      Thanks Al
      It’s covered by most books and beekeeping associations but often in more detail than needed, or just done badly …

  2. Bridget

    I am hoping you will discuss the thorny problem of swarm control in the bee house! I know it’s not vital to others but I am sure they will find it interesting. Our first year, before we had the bee house, we did an artifial swarm much as you describe. The next two years we must have got the prevention right though one of those years we had a couple of disappearing queens. Then last year we had our first swarm from the beehouse. This was Frasers first year as head beekeeper and possibly what with work and the weather we were a bit irregular with the inspections. It’s hard to do side by side manipulation. Last years swarm was hived into a hive we moved outside directly in front of an unoccupied entrance and then moved inside one evening .
    BTW six weeks into the desensitisation at Ninewells so will have some protection by May but think I will probably take the role of underkeeper where I will have the option to withdraw if things get heated. We are also trying to get some gentler queens!

    1. David Post author

      Hi Bridget
      I’m hoping (expecting!) to cover this in May/June when I have an opportunity to get some photos. I’ve so far coped with simply splitting off a nuc with the queen, then allowing the box to requeen itself. I think there may be more elegant methods and have one or two half-baked ideas I’d also like to try. With clipped queens – as mine are – and a reasonably clear area in front of the shed they simply crawl back and cluster around the entrance. Not ideal, but better than losing them over the fence perhaps. I also always try and have a bait hive tucked away in the corner of the apiary in the hope of tricking anything that does swarm to conveniently re-house themselves somewhere I can easily deal with them.
      Good to hear that the desensitisation is working. Gentle queens are good whether or not you’re sensitive – they’re so much nicer to work with. Inspections become a pleasure, rather than a chore to be avoided.
      Best Wishes

    2. Calum

      Works just the same in a beehouse, better if you have hives along two walls, you can swap the side of the building the old hive was on.

  3. Calum

    Generally I don’t bother looking for the queen, I’ll move the hive and set up a new one on the old site, it gets a frame or two with queen cells , a frame of emerging brood, a pollen frame and two frames of honey. So no hunt for a queen, the old colony looses all its flying bees and it’s motivation to swarm . Just have to destroy all the swarm cells remaining in the old hive. This method is better if your queen is unmarked as most of mine aren’t.

    1. David Post author

      Hi Calum
      Certainly many ways to achieve this … my intention was to describe the ‘vanilla’ procedure as a reference for the future. I wanted to keep it – the description, not the procedure – as simple as possible.

      1. Calum

        Yes and an excellent description it is to! Thank you!
        Looking for a method for doing the same in a Glotzbeute at the moment. Moving it is not an option….

          1. calum

            it is a hive containing 40 frames in 2 rows, seperated by a vertical queen excluder.
            The bee space is regulated with dummy boards. The frames are about Langstroth dimensions, but on their sides. As there is no stack there is no heavy lifting, and the whole hives activity can be assessed at a glance without disturbing very much…
            But it is too heavy to move in case they fancy swarming, so the atrificial swarm in managed by manipulating frames on either side of the dummy boards. . .

          2. David Post author

            Or presumably by simply taking a nuc out with the queen and letting the box requeen itself … unless the frames aren’t of a normal size. Which takes us back to compatability.

  4. Pingback: Queen cells ... don't panic! - The Apiarist

  5. Mike Gould

    If they are really wanting to swarm bees can take a 2 day old larva and raise that as a queen, capping the cell and swarming 3 days later.
    So theoretically to ensure that the queen-right colony on the old site (has queen, flying bees and some brood) doesn’t swam you would have to inspect every 2 days until you’re sure that they’ve given up on the idea.
    Does this sound like a real possibility? Some association courses are teaching that you still need to ensure the queen is clipped or place a queen-excluder under the brood box to be sure you don’t lose a swarm after the split. (or just make up a nuc instead of the whole palaver)

    1. David Post author

      If you separate the bees and leave the queen with a frame of emerging brood – no young larvae – you should be able to suppress the swarming instinct. The original hive is left with the queen, emerging brood and the flying bees. I’ve never put a QE below this box. I do clip my queens (or most of them). With no queen cells and no means of generating any for a few days and no young bees the swarming instinct should disappear. The new hive has swarm cells and the young bees. As the latter mature you can bleed them off by switching the box to the other side of the original hive. You need to reduce the strength of the new hive and – ideally – leave a single queen cell.
      Sorry it took so long to get round to this comment – it was lost in the system!

Comments are closed.